Albashir-Adam-Alhassan

US President Donald Trump, while speaking at a luncheon with Irish Prime Minister Edna Kenny, was quoted to have said:

As we stand together with our Irish friends, I’m reminded of that proverb — and this is a good one, this is one I like. I’ve heard it for many, many years and I love it. ‘Always remember to forget the friends that proved untrue. But never forget to remember those that have stuck by you.’ We know that, politically speaking. A lot of us know that, we know it well. It’s a great phrase.

The quote seems perfect, right? But here’s the kicker: the Irish have never heard the quote before! Many took to Twitter to express their confusion.

A few hours later, someone posted on Twitter this poem written about a decade ago by a Nigerian, Albashir Adam Alhassan.

trump-proverb

trump proverb Have you noticed the problem, yet? No? Okay, go back to Trump’s quote, see the part in bold? Now, read the second stanza of the poem. Yes, we were just as shocked.

Apparently, the shock was going around as the poet himself, upon being contacted, was quoted to have said, “My sister just brought the news to me. I didn’t want to believe what she said initially. I posted those things when I was back in school, over 10 years ago. I never thought it would get to this level.”

“Maybe I shouldn’t have been a banker, maybe I should have been a poet all my life!” he joked.

However, to some, this is not strange at all. In a tweet, the Nigerian poet and fiction writer, Tolu Ogunlesi, pointed out that there is nothing particularly original about those lines from the poem, even going as far as to suggest Alhassan himself might be the real plagiarist in the story. After all, Trump did not claim the quote as his in the first place.

This of course brings to light an interesting topic of discussion. Often, a line of thought could occur to different poets and they would express that same thought in similar manner. How much of this can one say to really be plagiarism? As Ogunlesi noted, those lines are quite generic and could have been written by different writers since there is nothing unique about its arrangement of words.

Hence the question: at what point do we know if similarities in works are just plagiarism or mere coincidences? Let us know what you think.

And, oh, where on earth did Trump get the info that it is an Irish proverb?

*****

Post image from Olisa.TV.

Tags: , , , , ,

About kanyinsola olorunnisola

View all posts by kanyinsola olorunnisola

3 Responses to “How Donald Trump Made the Nigerian Poet Albashir Alhassan Famous” Subscribe

  1. ezicat 2017/04/01 at 15:25 #

    Similar and “the exact same” are two very different things. Tolu Ogunlesi should stop making excuses for a person who would never makes excuses for him.

  2. Malam M.T.Danladi 2017/04/01 at 16:41 #

    Human experiences are universal and though we may live in different regions of this globe we can still react in similar ways given similar situations and which cannot be unusual. When for example I first saw the title of ‘Things Fall Apart’ by Chinua Achebe I never knew there was a poem of that title by a white romantic poet, Keats. Wole Soyinka’s famous remark ‘The man died who keep silent in the face of tyranny’ in his novel ‘The Man Died’ I later discovered isn’t originally made by him. Malcom X’s famous remark about change happening ‘by any means possible’ was first made in a play by a French playwright. So, whether Albashir is the originator of the poem or not, nobody is a repository of creativity and it is not unusual for two people from different regions to think the same way, once in a while.

  3. cookie 2017/04/01 at 21:58 #

    I am not exactly sure but I believe I have seen/heard this poem before 2007 which was when Alhassan supposedly uploaded/submitted to poemhunter. It sounds too familiar, like something I learned way back in school. CNN traced it back to 1936 as the work of Levi Furbush.. word for word. Though two writers can think the same way, the odds that it’s the case here is too low. There are lots of plagiarized poems on poemhunter anyway, it’s not a reliable source for original work. Even Gabriel Okara’s “You laughed” poem is beautifully plagiarized there. By a Nigerian of course.

    I understand the human need to jump into any opportunities but in this age of internet one must be careful not to claim work as his if it isn’t his. Just one google click and someone can make judgments on your integrity. There are many fact checkers who are willing to enter the sea to dig up facts. It’s not a big deal in Nig but for the rest of the world it really is. It’s better to paraphrase, or give simply credit to the source. And admit if it was a mistake. I learned the hard way when I moved to the USA.

Leave a Reply

I hold a doctorate in English from Duke University and recently joined the Marquette University English faculty as an Assistant Professor. I love teaching African fiction and contemporary British novels. Brittle Paper is the virtual space/station where I play and experiment with ideas on how to reinvent African fiction and literary culture.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Archives

#CainePrize2017 | Review of Lesley Nneka Arimah’s Who Will Greet You at Home? | By Socrates Mbamalu

brittle paper reviews (5)

Lesley Nneka Arimah was born in the UK and grew up mostly in Nigeria. Her story, “Light,” won the 2015 Commonwealth […]

The Labors of the Months: Of Work and Its Refuseniks | By Rotimi Babatunde

work naija vocation

  In October 2016, we published Enter Naija: The Book of Places, an anthology of creative nonfiction, photography, poetry, digital […]

Imbolo Mbue’s Behold The Dreamers Picked for Oprah’s Book Club

oprah mbue

Imbolo Mbue’s Behold the Dreamers has been selected by Oprah Winfrey for her Book Club. The media mogul revealed this […]

Chinelo Okparanta’s Under The Udala Trees Named Among the 25 Most Impactful LGBTQ Works of the Last 20 Years

chinelo okparanta

Chinelo Okparanta’s Under the Udala Trees has been listed as one of the 25 most impactful works of LGBTQ literature […]

Babishai Poetry Festival 2017 | Interview with Mugabi Byenkya, Author of Dear Philomena

BABISHAI 2017 FLYER PURPLE

As part of the countdown to the 2017 Babishai Poetry Festival in Uganda, the organisers are conducting a series of interviews […]

Teju Cole Releases Fourth Book Blind Spot | Read An Excerpt

teju cole--blind spot

Teju Cole does not repeat himself, which is why his new book, Blind Spot, published two weeks ago, is something unprecedented for […]