Subscribe to Newsletter
Monthly Newsletter: Join more than 3,000 African literature enthusiasts!
Subscribe for African literature news, and receive a free copy of our "Guide to African Novels."


Three novels were shortlisted for the 2016 NLNG Prize for Literature. These novels are Born on a Tuesday by Elnathan John, Season of Crimson Blossom by Abubakar Adam Ibrahim, and Night Dancer by Chika Unigwe. Abubakar’s book won. In the days that followed, save for the controversial 2016 Nobel Laureate in Literature, the media was friendly with Abubakar. His win has a monetary attachment of 100,000 dollars. He was interviewed. Literary festivals within Nigeria had him talk about his book. He has most likely been asked by journalists what he would do with the prize money. In a few more months, his win might be off the news. Abubakar might go back to writing or fixing some personal issues with his money.   

In the months leading up to the announcement of the winner, something was conspicuously missing. The web and print media barely received any critical writing on the three shortlisted books. There hasn’t been enough engaging debate about the books and the authors and their possibilities. The literary circle got busy with popular culture — life, Kim’s robbery in Paris, Kaffy’s caressing of a chicken on the front page of a magazine. Pop life is big news. Graduates of literature, perhaps, see it as uncool to spend about 10,000 of their hard earned Naira to purchase three books whose authors were on the list of being millionaires and talk about them.

I am a literary critic. The university I attended will graduate about 64 English and Literature majors in a few months. Some 50 more who combined other courses with English and Literature will also come out with a degree. The study of Literature prepares one for the life of literary criticism, but often times, it is just what it is—getting a university degree.

I am guilty. I have not read any of the books that made the shortlist. I have read short stories from the authors but not the shortlisted books. And I am particular with pop life, like my peers. And we have let down the tradition of literary criticism, the kind led by the likes of Professor Charles Nnolim and the late Isidore Okpewho.

Outside the committee for the NLNG Prize who were paid to screen the entries, no other scholar has done visible voluntary work on the books. Literary criticism sustains a literary work but not in Nigeria, currently. How then would a work survive if it is not talked about? Should the committee for the NLNG Prize pay special critics outside the circle to fuel debate on the entries yearly? Should they run a contest on the review of the shortlisted books across universities in the country so the books can be read? What about newspaper houses? Can they pay critics to review such shortlisted books and drive a debate?

It is amazing to have a huge sum as reward but can the NLNG Prize institute a nationwide tour and discussion in the geopolitical zones in Nigeria? Can there be residency attachment to the prize, something that can rotate among selected schools with facilities for such, so the winners can share their experiences and teach creative writing for at least six months? What are the steps that can be put in place for the rejuvenation of literary criticism? The Nigeria Academy of Letters: what do they do again? What about some international exposure with foreign universities? What would it take to get international media coverage of the prize and the conversations around the shortlisted works? Wouldn’t this help shoot up sales and increase demand for the authors and the publishers? Or can the NLNG run a centre for creative writing so the works by the winning authors can be studied and given to schools for free, since the prize money has taken care of copies? 

The prize should not just be about walking home with the prize money. It should also be about finding new audiences for the writer and creating a literary brand with a solid cultural capital. 


About the Author:

Portrait - NwiloBura-Bari Nwilo lives in Port Harcourt.  He is author of A Tiny Place Called Happiness – a collection of stories. 

Tags: ,

I hold a doctorate in English from Duke University and recently joined the Marquette University English faculty as an Assistant Professor. I love teaching African fiction and contemporary British novels. Brittle Paper is the virtual space/station where I play and experiment with ideas on how to reinvent African fiction and literary culture.

5 Responses to “The Dearth of Literary Criticism and the NLNG Prize For Literature | by Bura-Bari Nwilo” Subscribe

  1. Babajide Michael Olusegun 2016/11/23 at 02:00 #

    Before criticism there must have been “readism”. There is no more Print readism in Nigeria, what we have now is Social Media abridged version readism. Why. It is cheaper, faster and easier. All you need do? Just get a GLO Or Etisalat ‘mekunu’ data subscription and for a month, you are good to go. How many Nigerian author is online? Not even the Old and enriched ones like Pa Soyinka can be easily read. And it is rather unfortunate that many Nigerians don’t even know a bookshop or library exists except you are still a student. I hope I don’t end up starting a “Poverty Conversation” sha to use Elnathan’s phrase.
    It isn’t too much if the NLNG winner spends part of his prize to address some of the brilliant issues raised by Bura Bari. Well that is if he reads it anyway….

  2. Hannah 2016/11/23 at 04:29 #

    Fantastic article. The questions the author poses are salient ones. In certain quarters, the NLNG prize isn’t taken as seriously as other similar prizes in the world, likely due to a dearth of many of the points raised here. This, apart from the prize money which oftentimes seems obscene, and might be better split across the genres. But that aside, if there were to be conversations around the shortlisted books, with authors engaging with students and the like as per the author’s suggestions, it would go a long way to the prize being more ‘authentic’.

  3. Opia-Enwemuche Maxwell O. 2016/11/23 at 06:54 #

    Well-articulated article by the writer. In addition to a book being discussed or criticized, I would love the NLNG to also come up with a literary prize for unpublished manuscripts and set the age limit for 18 years and above. I believe this would also gain momentum. There should be transparency so to say in choosing winners as the judges should be announced beforehand.

    Also, after the presentation of the prize money, there should be a nationwide campaign which could spin into African countries with sponsor signing on. The idea is to bring life to writing and cause the citizens to engage in reading creative works. If other social programs like beauty pageantry gets this kind of coverage, then my thoughts and suggestions are not far from what should be done.

  4. Mike 2016/11/24 at 10:57 #

    Spot on.

  5. Su'eddie Vershima Agema 2016/12/25 at 18:28 #

    This is a really nice piece. Bura-Bari, there is much to do and I hope that more than just lament, as you have or be grateful for it, as we have, we should work towards building that which we want.
    I have read Elnathan’s book and Abubakar’s. I wrote a paper on the former but I need to complete a critical reading of Abubakar’s and Chika’s to do something better. There is much to do and I can only hope we get the time, commitment and discipline to face the work that we are meant to face. Well done Bura-Bari. Well done.

Leave a Reply

Welcome to Brittle Paper, your go-to site for African writing and literary culture. We bring you all the latest news and juicy updates on publications, authors, events, prizes, and lifestyle. Follow us on Twitter and Instagram (@brittlepaper) and sign up for our "I love African Literature" newsletter.

Monthly Newsletter!

Subscribe for African literature news, and receive a free copy of our
"Guide to African Novels."


Purple Hibiscus Journal | Clementine Ewokolo-Burnley | Nonfiction

purple hibiscus workshop

There is water everywhere, a skyline, tall buildings, twinkling lights, pleasure craft behind locked gates. Leaning back in the taxi, […]

The Longlist for the 2018 Golden Baobab Prize Announced

golden baobab prize

The longlist for the 2018 Golden Baobab Prize is out. The prizes provide opportunities for African writers and illustrators to […]

PHOTOS | Bambooks Limited Launches Mobile Reading App and Announces Monthly Subscription Service

FictionPoetryEssay&ThinkPiece (1)

There is a myth that says Africans do not read and if you want to hide something from them put […]

Africa in Dialogue Publishes Interview e-Book with 2017 Brittle Paper Awards Winners: Sisonke Msimang, Hawa Golakai, JK Anowe, Megan Ross, Chibuihe Achimba

brittle paper 2017 winners - graph

Leading interview magazine Africa in Dialogue has published an e-book of interviews with the winners of the 2017 Brittle Paper Awards. […]

James Murua’s Literature Blog Wins at Sanaa Theatre Awards

james murua - graph

Our colleagues at James Murua’s Literature Blog are among the winners of the 2018 Sanaa Theatre Awards in Kenya. The […]

Previously Unseen Stories by Naguib Mahfouz Set for December Publication

naguib mahfouz graph - cairo trilogy - raptis books

Previously unseen short stories by the late Egyptian Nobel Prize laureate Naguib Mahfouz will be published on 11 December, his […]

Thanks for signing up!

Never miss out on new posts. Subscribe to a digest, too:

No thanks, I only want the monthly newsletter.