8617836982_bbe85d494a_k

Writivism recently published the remarks of the 2013 Writivism Short Story Prize judges regarding submissions on its site. The previously-unreleased comments feature savagely frank evaluations of the general quality of the submissions of the first edition of the prize.

Ugandan writer, Ernest Bazanye, who is also the author of The Ballad of Black Bosco and one of the judges, voiced strong opinions:

 “The problem with the arts is that there is a constituency of people who assume that the intention and effort are enough, that wanting to and trying to are sufficient. I have found that there are people who are so enamored of the glamour or prestige they assume comes from being an artist that they pursue these instead of pursuing art itself. They want to be writers. They try to be writers. But they don’t want to write. And they don’t try to write. Instead they just cobble together whatever will pass…and we let them get away with it. Whatever the reason, this is how we ruin our own literature. By allowing people who do not even have the respect for the art, let alone the basics, the very basic skills, to represent it.”

Getting specific difficulty of finding submissions of high quality, Bazanye adds:

“There are typos and mistakes. Everybody makes them. I am sure I have made one or two already. But then there is also flat-out negligence or carelessness or the casual refusal to learn. That is why I rejected most of these stories, they are just bad. Poor grammar and punctuation are criminal. They make a mockery of what we are trying to do as…writers.”

Can we just say that we are glad someone is finally calling out the hawkers of bad writing as “the future” of African literature? Kudos to him for saying what needed to be said.

We do hope this inspires more emerging African writers to get more serious about their craft.

We are definitely sold on this tough love. Way to go, Ernest.

Read full comments here.

************

Post image by KOMUnews via Flickr.

Tags: , ,

About kanyinsola olorunnisola

View all posts by kanyinsola olorunnisola

3 Responses to “Writivism Judge Makes Brutally Honest Remark About Submissions” Subscribe

  1. cm 2017/03/11 at 06:08 #

    I hope brittle paper practices what is being preached here. I cannot tell you how many times on this site that I have dropped a short story because of typos and poor grammar.

  2. Tola 2017/03/11 at 23:01 #

    LaEven this judge who is talking about poor grammar and punctuation has made an unforgivable grammatical error. Except, of course, his statements weren’t properly quoted. I fear that my Writivislalam story will be unfairly judged by him.

  3. Tola 2017/03/11 at 23:08 #

    *Even *Writivism

Leave a Reply

I hold a doctorate in English from Duke University and recently joined the Marquette University English faculty as an Assistant Professor. I love teaching African fiction and contemporary British novels. Brittle Paper is the virtual space/station where I play and experiment with ideas on how to reinvent African fiction and literary culture.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Archives

On Helen Oyeyemi | An Essay

helen oyeyemi (1)

It was Helen Oyeyemi who first made me realize what I’d always found dissatisfying about short stories. A short story […]

Tsitsi Dangaremgba to Teach Master Classes at Durban International Film Festival

TSITSI DANGAREMBGA

Tsitsi Danganrembga, the renowned Zimbabwean writer and filmmaker who gave us the groundbreaking novel Nervous Conditions, will be teaching master […]

Africa in Dialogue Publishes e-Book of Gerald Kraak Award Interviews

gerald kraak interviews africa in dialogue

Gaamangwe Mogami, editor of Africa in Dialogue, has curated interviews with the twelve writers and photographers shortlisted for the 2017 Gerald […]

Bernard Matambo’s Lyrical Emigrant Story Makes Best American Essays 2017

bernard matambo

The Zimbabwean Bernard Matambo’s lyrical emigrant nonfiction, “Working the City,” published in Transition‘s issue 121 and named in Brittle Paper‘s […]

Chika Unigwe’s Student Writes Her the Letter Every Professor Dreams of Receiving

19095277_10155480594766055_8764199255508426184_o

African writers who are professors seem to have a knack for effortlessly winning the hearts of their students. In 2013, […]

Eight Writers Shortlisted for Writivism’s Short Story and Koffi Addo Nonfiction Prizes

Writivism has announced the shortlists for their Short Story and Koffi Addo Nonfiction Prizes. Both prizes’ longlists, released last month, named […]