A Greek Slave and a Manga Figure by Ali Altaf Mian

Ali Altaf Mian is a friend and a fellow blogger. Dwellings of Thought is the place where he shares insightful and delightful reflections on everything from Lady Gaga to Hegel. He is also a graduate student of Religion at Duke University. Last week I made a post, Geishas and Graffiti, showcasing graffiti pieces by a UK-based street artist named HUSH. Ali noticed the historical narrative embedded in the artwork and left a comment, initiating a conversation that we then continued on Facebook.  Ali’s deep thoughts on the artwork was not something I could keep to myself, so at some point in the conversation, I had to stop and ask him to write a short response that I could post on Brittle Paper, which he kindly did.  Enjoy Ali’s wise reading of HUSH’s fascinating graffiti as a historical account of the feminine.

Dis-grace-D I by HUSH

The work of art titled “Dis-grace-D I” by HUSH invokes both history and subjectivity. The four figures depicted here trace a genealogy of representation of the feminine. The manga figure, which is the centerpiece of the work, looks away from all three. While the three in the background, so to speak, do not have a singular gaze either. The perspectival look of each is different. Moreover, all four differ in their positions, highlighting “position” as one of the 9 Aristotelian accidents that individuates units within the same form. The one to the left of the manga figure is modeled on “The Greek Slave” by Hiram Powers (1851), which might be based on the “Venus de’ Medici” in the Uffizi Gallery in Florence, Italy.

Greek Slave Hiram Powers (1851)

I see the Greek slave and the manga figure creating a dialectic of female bondage and freedom, with the two other ones looking down upon, and participating in, this dialectic in their own ways. The one directly atop, yet slightly to the right, of “The Greek Slave” is most likely evocative of modernity, while the one juxtaposed next to it, in the upper right hand corner, is suggestive of early modern, or even late medieval, representations of the feminine countenance. I say that the “The Greek Slave” and the manga figure create the two poles of the dialectic because if you look at the respective directions of their faces, the Greek figure’s face is most turned away from us, while the manga figure’s face is most readily available to us. The other two create fields of vision that intersect with the dialectic of subjectivity being orchestrated here. In its own way, this work invites us to see where our vision intersects with this historical genealogy of the feminine. It makes sense, then, to title the piece, “Dis-grace-D I,” which invokes all of the following possibilities for those affected by this piece through engaging it:
1) feeling disgrace
2) feeling grace
3) Being disgraced
4) Being graced

Tags: , , , ,

I hold a doctorate in English from Duke University and recently joined the Marquette University English faculty as an Assistant Professor. I love teaching African fiction and contemporary British novels. Brittle Paper is the virtual space/station where I play and experiment with ideas on how to reinvent African fiction and literary culture.

2 Responses to “A Greek Slave and a Manga Figure by Ali Altaf Mian” Subscribe

  1. Chibuzor 2011/06/16 at 16:42 #

    Quite Insightful!

  2. Boye 2012/01/30 at 15:27 #

    Thanks for revealing what I only previously looked at.

Leave a Reply

I hold a doctorate in English from Duke University and recently joined the Marquette University English faculty as an Assistant Professor. I love teaching African fiction and contemporary British novels. Brittle Paper is the virtual space/station where I play and experiment with ideas on how to reinvent African fiction and literary culture.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Archives

Lesley Nneka Arimah Picked for the US National Book Foundation’s “5 Under 35” List

Lesley Nneka Arimah has been picked for the US National Book Foundation’s “5 Under 35” list of 2017, on the […]

The Photographer as an Osprey | John “Lighthouse” Oyewale | Essay

On 30 June, we published Work Naija: The Book of Vocations, an anthology of writing and visual art that explores the […]

Zukiswa Wanner Calls Out Misogyny in South Africa, Kenya and Zimbabwe, Takes on Politicians and the Media

Zukiswa Wanner has called out misogyny in South Africa, Kenya and Zimbabwe, taking on politicians and the media in the […]

Dinaw Mengestu and Nadifa Mohamed Have New Work in Freeman’s Magazine

Nadifa Mohamed

Dinaw Mengestu and Nadifa Mohammed both have new fiction forthcoming in the new fourth issue of Freeman’s magazine. Titled “The Future […]

The Brittle Paper Literary Awards: New Date for the Announcement of Winners

The announcement of the winners of the inaugural Brittle Paper Literary Awards was scheduled for 23 September 2017. However, a change […]

The Reviews Are In! | Namwali Serpell Has High Praise for Jennifer Makumbi’s Kintu

Screen-Shot-2017-09-20-at-4.57.42-PM-e1505944728679 copy

Jennifer Makumbi’s Kintu is one of the hit novels of 2017. A historical drama, it tells the story of an 18th […]