Subscribe to Newsletter
Monthly Newsletter: Join more than 5,000 African literature enthusiasts!
Subscribe for African literature news, and receive a free copy of our "Guide to African Novels."

On April 14, acting in my capacity as editor of Brittle Paper, I made the editorial call to pull down a story about the Twitter outrage against Hadiza Elrufai’s response to a statement made by her son. My then deputy, Otosirieze Obi-Young had covered the story and published it on the front page of Brittle Paper before I could review it.

Otosirieze’s post was an impassioned, deeply personal piece reporting on the reprehensible statement made by Hadiza El Rufai about her son’s equally odious statement. I found the title inflammatory and unnecessarily incendiary, but everything seemed fine until I got to the last paragraph. It was then that alarms rang in my mind.

This paragraph read as follows:

Interestingly, four hours after backlash began to her response, an article appeared on ThisDay titled “Endearing Qualities of Kaduna First Lady, Hadiza El Rufai.” It is exactly as shabbily-written as you would expect of a hastily assembledface-washing gimmick. But it is not as unintelligent as the one on OperaNews.

There must be a name for this feminism whose reply to “Tell your mother I’m passing her to my friends tonight” is “I didn’t see any threats of rape.” A feminism that agrees to raise men to be better but says “All is fair in love and war” when their ethnic-bigoted men-children threaten violence on women’s bodies.

Shame. Shame. Shame. Shame.

Do better.

It was not clear why he was accusing two Nigerian newspapers of writing “hastily assembled, face-washing gimmick” and another of being “unintelligent”. And why was the diatribe “shame! Shame! Shame! Shame!” being used in what should have been a plain reportage of facts and written statements and tweets? It seemed to be histrionic, inflammatory, even melodramatic and totally not in keeping with the seriousness of the matter he was addressing.

I felt, and feel, Otosirieze’s outrage. I am both a woman and the mother of a daughter. Suggesting that a woman should be sexually assaulted is unconscionable and needs a hard and swift response. But in condemning such statements, it is important that we ourselves do not stoop to the level of those making them. It is important that we do not abandon completely all principles and ethics in how we write.

In the age of social media, I have become particularly sensitive to making sure that everything we do on Brittle Paper, from titles to all content are crafted with care. I disdain clickbait and try to minimize the use of coarse language.  Using “gang rape” in the title where something like “lewd comments” would have sufficed seemed gratuitous. These were some of the editorial questions running through my mind when I called Otosirieze to tell him that the post needed editing. My call with him did not go well. He sounded upset on the phone and seemed unable to completely see why the paragraph accusing Thisday and OperaNews of unethical behavior without any proof was not only problematic but also potentially libelous.

After insisting for ten minutes, he grudgingly agreed to remove the last paragraph. Unfortunately, he refused to edit the title, which I felt to be unnecessarily incendiary. He refused to do so, even as I tried to suggest alternative titles. Unfortunately, this all occurred at a time I had to prepare time sensitive lectures for my students, and without sufficient time to edit the post. The time difference between Nigeria and the US also left me with little time to act quickly, so I pulled the post down as the exigent thing to do.

I have run Brittle Paper for 10 years. In that time, I have made more than my fair share of mistakes, but I have also learned a lot. I have become increasingly aware of how important it is to be careful with language so that it produces meaning as opposed to obfuscation. I am also careful to ensure that we do not accuse without proof, and that we do not defame any persons, intentionally or unintentionally.  As a literature professor who teaches a course on social media, words have become even more sacred to me as I watch the public sphere spiral into chaos because non-discerning orators compete for the most irreverent rhetoric.

I took no issue with Otosirieze’s post except for the highly sensationalized reporting and the potentially libelous reference to two Nigerian newspapers. If any of the journalists whose pieces he mentioned were to sue Brittle Paper for libel, the buck would have stopped with me, and not with Otosirieze.

I am stunned that what was essentially an editorial matter has spilled into theatrical war over censorship fueled by conspiracy theories. At no time during my conversation did I suggest that the article should not be published or that it was not newsworthy.  This whole matter could have been resolved if we had managed to come to an agreement about making the story less incendiary and less libelous. Otosirieze hung up on me as I tried to explain why the story would have to be pulled down, and refused to engage on this issue professionally.

In his initial statement on April 14, he misrepresented me by suggesting that I pulled down the post to suppress his voice. Brittle Paper’s record against censorship, and its record in celebration of all writers stands for itself. It is on the record that Brittle Paper has never shied away from controversial issues. We reported on this, this and this, and those pieces remain online, even when they were about far more powerful people. When I realized our working relationship had broken down irretrievably, I removed Otosirieze’s access to Brittle Paper and its accounts on other digital platforms.

I am extremely disappointed, indeed, I am deeply wounded that my wonderful cooperation with a writer whose talent and work ethic I always admired has ended in this way. Otosirieze was not only a valued partner at Brittle Paper, he was a trusted friend.

I am particularly disappointed that he has chosen not to correct several allegations that he knows for certain to be falsehoods.  For instance, Brittle Paper has never been funded by the Kaduna state government. Further, I am not a misogynist. Nor by any stretch of the imagination could I ever be called a supporter of rapists. I also find it astonishing and worrying that he would try to link me and Brittle Paper to any sort of danger to his person when he knows fully well that I have no connection to the state of Kaduna or the federal government of Nigeria, for that matter.

More than anyone, Otosirieze knows that I run Brittle Paper on my personal income. He knows that I have never taken a kickback, or any dime from any foundation, individual, or corporation. He knows the sacrifice that has gone into building Brittle Paper. As someone I considered a friend, Otosirieze also knows my values, knows what I believe in and stand for, and knows that I would never under any circumstances be found on the side of anyone advocating rape.  I consider his failure to speak out against these attacks on my character to be a deep betrayal because he has stood by and gloated while a group of persons who do not know me at all have tried to burn my hard work to the ground and have defamed my character with falsehoods that he knows to be such.

Nonetheless, I deeply appreciate all the work that Otosirieze committed to Brittle Paper over the last four years. I am sorry that we have had to part with this bad blood between us and wish him the very best in what is certain to be a stellar writing career. I also wish to thank the many readers who have supported me in this difficult time. I am willing to be judged both by Brittle Paper’s past work, and its future endeavors, confident in the certainty that the truth will always shine through. Brittle Paper will continue to celebrate African literature in ways that have always inspired readers.

 

________________

 

Ainehi Edoro is an Assistant Professor of English at the University of Wisconsin-Madison where she teaches African literature. She received her doctorate at Duke University. She is the founder and editor of Brittle Paper and series editor of Ohio University Press’s Modern African Writer’s imprint.

80 Responses to “Statement on the Departure of Brittle Paper’s Former Deputy Editor” Subscribe

  1. Akin April 17, 2020 at 4:36 am #

    He said, she said.

    At the end of the day, an author supported her son’s threat to gang-rape a woman. A deputy editor put up a post on Brittle Paper criticising said author. That post was removed, and the deputy editor was fired.

    It doesn’t matter whether the ex-deputy editor refused to change the headline or remove a sentence. All these are inconsequential.

    The real issue is, an author supported her son’s threat to gang-rape a woman, and the post criticising said author no longer exists on Brittle Paper.

    The message thus remains: Brittle Paper supports the author in question, and will not – for any reason – allow anyone publish a negative article about this author.

    We won’t forget this. I promise you.

  2. Ada April 17, 2020 at 5:31 am #

    Nothing you said here makes any sense.it’s a lame effort to cover up your gross display of immorality.Sacking a dedicated staff because of your allegiance to some derelict government will be the beginning of your undoing. I hope you’ll enjoy the turn in events.
    Isn’t it saddening that you had to betray your conscience this way?
    Shame!

  3. Nifemi April 17, 2020 at 12:04 pm #

    A big shame to you! You had time to put this together and didn’t have the time to “edit the title” of his report? It doesn’t add up!

    Shame to you for supporting rapists and their apologists.

  4. DELE EFFIONG April 19, 2020 at 8:48 am #

    MARK MY WORDS, A HYPOCRITE WILL NEVER SEE FARTHER THAN HIS NOSE.
    SORRY I MEANT “HER” ….

  5. Vivian Zems April 20, 2020 at 12:32 am #

    This is hard for you, and being a boss means you sometimes have to make tough decisions. Brittle Paper is your baby, and you must stay true to it (I speak as an author and blogger).
    Stay strong, don’t bother defending your actions ( people have already made their minds up- like in the Crucifixion)- and keep pouring yourself into this brilliant paper.
    I’m rooting for you!!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. OF NIGERIA’S UNCOUTH POLITICAL ELITES, ANGRY BACKLASH AND COERCED APOLOGIES. Bello El Rufai Vs Nigerians Vs Hadiza El Rufai Vs Otorisieze Vs Brittle Papers. – Afrikajump - April 18, 2020

    […] enough. He got fired, the article got edited, Nigeria twitter caught on more fire, BP gave their statement, the inferno […]

  2. The Full Story: Former Deputy Editor, Otosirieze Obi-Young and Brittle Paper Founder, Ainehi Edoro Are Locked In A theatrical War - Creative Writing News - May 1, 2020

    […] Founding Editor, Ainehi Edoro, wrote, in her statement, also posted on April 15, 2020: “Nonetheless, I deeply appreciate all the work that […]

  3. What’s on our minds: Trouble at Brittle Paper, Vay’s panic attack over insecurity in our neighborhoods, and Netflix, Instagram set up platform for mental health - Addavi - June 7, 2020

    […] Vay: Read this. […]

Leave a Reply

Welcome to Brittle Paper, your go-to site for African writing and literary culture. We bring you all the latest news and juicy updates on publications, authors, events, prizes, and lifestyle. Follow us on Twitter and Instagram (@brittlepaper) and sign up for our "I love African Literature" newsletter.

Monthly Newsletter!

Subscribe for African literature news, and receive a free copy of our
"Guide to African Novels."

Archives

Nnedi Okorafor’s LaGuardia Wins 2020 Hugo Award for Best Graphic Story or Comic

Nnedi Okorafor's LaGuardia Wins 2020 Hugo Award for Best Graphic Story or Comic (3)

Nigeria’s Nnedi Okorafor is on a roll! Barely two weeks since bagging an Eisner Award, Okarafor wins the coveted Hugo […]

Ugandan Novelist Jennifer Makumbi on All-Female Short Story Prize Longlist

Jennifer Makumbi on All-Female Short Story Prize Longlist

Celebrated Ugandan author Jennifer Makumbi is on the longlist of the 2020 Edge Hill Short Story Prize for her debut […]

Is Oedipus Rex a Form of Detective Fiction? — Watch Episode 5 of Prof. Ato Quayson’s Vlog

Is Oedipus Rex a Form of Detective Fiction_ --- Watch Episode 5 of Prof. Ato Quayson's Vlog

The fifth episode of Professor Ato Quayson’s vlog Critic.Reading.Writing is up! As the literary vlog enters its fifth week, Quayson […]

Wole Soyinka Writes Letter of Solidarity for Detained Humanist Mubarak Bala

Soyinka2

Nobel Laureate Wole Soyinka has never hesitated to speak out in the face of injustice. He recently penned a letter […]

Kenyan Filmmaker Wanuri Kahiu and Ghanaian American Playwright Jocelyn Bioh Collaborating on a Disney+ Project

once on this island wanuri kahiu joselyn bioh (1)

Wanuri Kahiu will direct the Disney+ film adaptation of the Broadway musical, Once on This Island, reports Hollywood Reporter. Ghanaian-American […]

Treasure is a New Novella by Oyinkan Braithwaite

Braithwaite3

Calling all fans of My Sister, the Serial Killer! Oyinkan Braithwaite has a new novella out. Titled Treasure, the book […]

Thanks for signing up!

Never miss out on new posts. Subscribe to a digest, too:

No thanks, I only want the monthly newsletter.